The Augusta Chronicle reported the settlement between James M. Mason and his family and the Augusta nursing home The Place at Deans Bridge Road.  Mason was admitted to The Place at Deans Bridge Road on Sept. 24, 2012. He was 62 and in need of skilled nursing care.  Mason developed urinary tract infections, injuries from numerous falls, dehydration, weight loss and renal failure. After he was hospitalized with pneumonia in September 2015, his family Mason moved to Golden Living. He died Nov. 3, 2015.

The litigation against the owner/operator Golden Living Center and its nursing home administrator Elize Joseph continues. The family alleged that neglect led to a Mason’s injuries and suffering by putting corporate profits above patient care by not staffing at adequate levels to provide residents proper care.

Harris agreed to a one-time lump sum payment, the amount is to remain confidential under the agreement. Attorney fees and court cost, and medical expenses for his father will come out of the settlement payment.

The Healthcare Finance News reported the settlement between Prestige Healthcare and the U.S. Department of Justice.  Based in Louisville, Kentucky, Prestige is an owner and operator of nursing homes in several states.  Prestige Healthcare has agreed to pay the federal government nearly $1 million to resolve allegations that it violated the False Claims Act in a scheme to falsely bill Medicare for unnecessary genetic testing, according to the U.S. Department of Justice.

Nursing home operators such as Prestige place orders with clinical laboratories for medically necessary diagnostic laboratory tests for their residents. In order to be considered medically necessary and thus reimbursable under Medicare, the laboratory test must be ordered by the physician treating the resident.

The allegations charge Prestige with failing to ensure that physician orders were obtained for the genetic testing prior to its being conducted, and that Prestige physicians were not aware of, and did not agree with, the medical necessity of the testing.

The United States alleged that in 2014 Prestige was approached by an entity known as Genomix, which claimed that it could perform genetic testing on Prestige’s Medicare residents in order to ascertain whether those patients were properly metabolizing their medications. The federal government alleged that in 2014 and 2015, Prestige provided Genomix with insurance and personal medical information, as well as access to patients in nursing homes in several states for purposes of conducting the testing. Genomix conducted the testing by taking cheek swabs of each Prestige patient and then sending the cheek swab to a laboratory for analysis.

Prestige failed to ensure that its patients were informed of the testing prior to its being conducted, and provided with the opportunity to decline the testing.

The DOJ said the lack of physician orders and patient consent was discovered during a survey conducted by state regulators in late 2015.


Bobby Glenn Tweed was admitted to a nursing home in January 2013.  While diagnosed with dementia, Tweed, 78, was still a vigorous man. But without his family’s consent, Tweed was given dangerous psychotropic drugs that are known to be fatal among older patients with dementia. In 10 months, he was dead.

The AARP reported the that with the help of AARP Foundation lawyers, Tweed’s family settled a wrongful death lawsuit against the nursing home and others that were responsible for caring for their father. Terms of the settlement are confidential.

The dangerous overuse of psychotropic drugs in nursing facilities received widespread national attention from an AARP Bulletin investigative report in the July-August 2014 issue.

“After that story, we started hearing from people all over the country whose loved ones suffered because they had received these drugs often without consent,” said Kelly Bagby, senior attorney with AARP Foundation Litigation.

“These lawsuits are among the efforts of AARP Foundation to help address this nationwide health crisis,” Bagby said. “Unfortunately, what happened to Mr. Tweed has happened to countless others.”

The practice is done for the convenience of understaffed nursing homes where the care is inadequate, according to experts.


A North Carolina federal jury determined that a nursing home committed negligence that caused the deaths of three patients, with reckless disregard to their rights, and awarded their families $5.2 million in compensatory and punitive damages.

After a four-day trial, the jury determined that medical care given by nursing home Blue Ridge Health Care Center and management companies Care Virginia Management LLC and Care One LLC was grossly negligent, intentional or in reckless disregard of the rights of Del Ray Baird, Jacqueline Baird, and Elizabeth Jones.

Plaintiffs, administrators of the estates of deceased persons who were residents of North Carolina at the time of their deaths, and Samuel Kee, Sr., individually, filed the original complaint in Wake County Superior Court on December 23, 2013. On January 28, 2014, Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint. In the amended complaint plaintiffs bring state law claims for medical and/or professional negligence, ordinary corporate negligence, ordinary negligence, wrongful death, intentional and negligent infliction of emotional distress, breach of contract, and punitive damages.

These allegations stem from the treatment and deaths of three individuals while being cared for at the Blue Ridge Health Care Center (“BRHCC”) facility at 3830 Blue Ridge Road, Raleigh, NC 27612. Defendant Blue Ridge of Raleigh, LLC (“Blue Ridge”) is alleged to have held the license to operate the nursing home, BHRCC, where each of
the deaths occurred in this case.  See Order denying Motion to Dismiss..

The Waco Tribune reported that a jury found that Jeffrey Place Rehabilitation Center officials were negligent in their care of a blind, diabetic Waco man and compensated the man’s family $450,000 in actual damages. Homer Byrd, a 79-year-old retired tractor mechanic, died in November 2015, only a month after being admitted to Jeffrey Place.

Jurors deliberated about 7½ hours over two days before siding with Greg H. Byrd and his wife, Kim, in their wrongful death lawsuit against the Waco nursing center and its parent company, Senior Living Properties LLC.

Testimony from the five-day trial showed that Byrd, a diabetic on dialysis, developed an infected big toe that turned gangrenous, which led to Byrd’s right leg being amputated just above his knee and, ultimately, to his death.

Jeffrey Place staff breached the ordinary standard of care by failing to promptly discover and treat the infected toe. Nurses testified they noticed the toe, but not until the wound had turned black, had a foul odor and was 4 centimeters by 5 centimeters.


The awards include $100,000 for pain and mental anguish suffered by Homer Byrd before his death, $75,000 for Greg Byrd’s loss of his father’s companionship and love and $75,000 for Greg Byrd’s mental anguish over his father’s death. The jury awarded $200,000 in deterrent damages so this type of neglect doesn’t happen again.


“Due to the evidence we saw, it was just gross negligence,” juror Crocker said. “There was a lot more that could have been done for this man, and it was just absolute refusal to see a problem that is blatantly obvious.”


The Chicago Sun Times reported the $875,000 settlement for the family of a man who choked to death at the facility in 2012.  Antonio Mares died after a nursing assistant at the Center Home for Hispanic Elderly fed him food that was not safe; failed comply with his physician’s diet orders; and violated the resident’s care plan.  He choked while eating without proper supervision.

The Levin & Perconti law firm announced the settlement. The family’s attorneys faulted understaffing and improper training for Mares’ death. Mares’ daughter, Isela Mares, says she hopes “needed changes” will be made at the nursing home.

A certified nursing assistant who was assigned to assist Mares with his evening meal set up the food tray on his table, positioned him to begin eating then stepped away from the area. Mares ate the food unsupervised and began to choke.

After realizing that Mares was choking, the nursing assistant unsuccessfully attempted to perform the Heimlich maneuver. He also used the call light to ask for help, but no one responded. Mares was later pronounced dead after further life-saving efforts also proved unsuccessful.

“Our family was robbed of the opportunity to properly say goodbye to my father, and while no sum of money will ever make up for our loss, we are hopeful that this settlement will incentivize the nursing home to make some needed changes,” Mares’ daughter, Isela Mares, said in the statement.


The Augusta Chronicle reported the settlement between Amara Health Care, also known as Salem Nursing and Rehab, and its chief executive officer Douglas Mittleider and Norma Manning on the eve of trial.  The terms of settlements are often confidential with no admission of liability.

Manning filed the 2013 lawsuit over the death of her husband of 18 years, Patrick Manning.  Patrick Manning suffered a stroke in 2011. He remained communicative and ambulatory but needed rehab services. He was sent to Amara. Five months later, he could no longer walk to the bathroom. In 16 months, Manning was dead. He had gangrenous pressure sores, dehydration, malnutrition and severe contracture, a condition in which a person’s limbs remained clutched close to the body.

“All I can say is that it was resolved to the satisfaction of the parties,” said attorney Caleb Connor, whose firm represented Manning.

Amara, or Salem, has been sued a number of times in the past 10 years over its care of patients. It also consistently rated below average in the nursing home inspection rating system of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid.

The 213-bed facility went into bankruptcy and was purchased at a bankruptcy auction in May by University Hospital for $3.7 million, according to an earlier report in The Augusta Chronicle.

The Globe Gazette reported the $900,000 verdict against Good Shepherd for the neglect of Maria Savas O’Brien. The jury, which deliberated for about 2½ hours on Friday afternoon and for more than six hours on Monday, determined Good Shepherd was negligent in its care of O’Brien.

The jury also determined the nursing home showed willful and wanton disregard for the rights and safety of another.

Savas O’Brien was at Good Shepherd for 2½ years. She was taken from Good Shepherd to the hospital in late March 2015 and died in early April 2015 at age 84 while in hospice care.

Expert witnesses for the family testified during the nine-day trial that a fall O’Brien had in March 2014 caused a downfall in her health and was preventable. Testimony also was presented alleging possible medication overdoses and staff failure to follow Savas O’Brien’s care plan, and mice in her room that left droppings on her bed, her bedside table and her religious icons.

She weighed 127 pounds when she entered the nursing home and lost 43 pounds while she was there.

O’Brien’s children will receive $150,000 in damages as compensation for her past physical and mental pain and suffering while she was at Good Shepherd. The family also is entitled to $750,000 in punitive damages, according to the jury.

O’Brien’s children — Kristine Christensen, Stephanie Prohaski, Anthony Savas and Theodore Savas —feel vindicated.

She said they did not file the lawsuit “to make a fortune” but to hold Good Shepherd accountable.

“Hopefully nursing homes will remember they are dealing with loved ones’ lives” and treat residents “the way they deserve to be treated,” Prohaski said.

The Globe Gazette reported on the nursing home trial in Iowa involving Good Shepherd nursing home.  Maria O’Brien’s children claim their mother died as the result of Good Shepherd’s negligence.  O’Brien was at Good Shepherd for two and a half years. She was admitted to the hospital in late March 2015 and died in early April 2015.

Byron Arbeit, a licensed nursing home administrator from Florida who now acts as an expert consultant for nursing homes, testified O’Brien developed avoidable conditions such as severe weight loss and skin problems.  Arbeit testified that the facility provided substandard care for Maria.  Good Shepherd did not meet the standard of care for Maria O’Brien that “respected her dignity as a human being,” said Byron Arbeit.  O’Brien also had avoidable falls while she was at Good Shepherd, according to Arbeit.  Steps could have been taken to prevent O’Brien’s numerous falls at Good Shepherd, such as having her in a common area rather than in a room by herself.

Mice in her room left droppings on her bed, her bedside table and her religious icons, he said. Bedbugs were also an issue, according to Arbeit.

During his opening statement, Benjamin Long, one of the attorneys for O’Brien’s family, said she initially was placed at Kentucky Ridge Assisted Living due to a mild case of dementia but went to Good Shepherd so she could recuperate from a broken pelvis after she fell.  O’Brien weighed 127 pounds when she was admitted to Good Shepherd but only weighed 84 pounds when she went to the hospital a few days before her death, Long said.

WREG reported the jury’s verdict compensating the family of a neglected resident at Allenbrooke Nursing Home and Rehabilitation Center in Memphis.  The unanimous jury decided that $30 million was fair and just to compensate the family, and to punish and deter similar conduct in the future.  Of course, the insurance company will attempt to rely on legal technicalities to challenge the jury’s verdict and avoid taking responsibility for the injuries they caused.

Martha Jane Pierce moved into Allenbrooke after her dementia just became too difficult for her family to handle on their own.  Her husband of 60 years soon followed.  She could walk and  didn’t have any skin breakdowns or bed sores.

However, Mrs. Pierce got worse and had to make several trips to and from the hospital for dehydration and malnutrition.  This contributed to the development of a pressure injury or pressure ulcer.  The failure to treat the ulcer or relieve the pressure caused the ulcer to increase in size and depth including reaching all the way to her bone.  The foot ulcer developed an infection because of the facility’s neglect which led to her leg being amputated.   The lawsuit proved that  many of the problems at the nursing home were due to a lack of staffing.

Her family sued the nursing home, its parent company and several other executives a year after her death. Last week, after years of delays, a jury ruled in their favor and returned a verdict with damages worth more than $30 million.